It’s a source of constant debate here in our town: where can you get the very best pizza in the area? We’ve got plenty of great pizzerias to choose from here in Butler, PA, so the question can be a controversial one. To add our voice to this ongoing argument, we decided to put together a list of our five favorite spots to grab a slice here in town. Check them out for a pie that is sure to please.
1. Mac’s Brick Oven Pizzeria
If you’ve never experienced the difference a brick oven makes in the taste of your pie’s crust, you’ve got to get down to Mac’s to give their authentic brick-oven style pies. Their White Traditional pie shows you that you don’t need tomato sauce to make a decent slice, topped with fresh garlic, oregano, basil, a blend of mozzarella and parmesan cheese with a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil for a refreshing flavor.
2. Villa Grande Ristorante and Pizzeria
While any of the Italian classics served up at Villa Grande are worth checking out, it’s hard to beat the pies they bake up here. Our favorite is their Ricotta and Meatballs pie, with homemade meatballs complimented perfectly by dollops of ricotta cheese and fresh mozzarella, all served on a base of San Marzano tomato sauce. Get yours with a side of their tasty tomato bruschetta.
3. Tani’s
Conveniently located just off of Butler Street, Tani’s is the go-to spot for many locals when they’re craving a slice. After trying it out for ourselves, we can certainly see why. We tried the Florence pie, and were treated to some zesty flavors from the ricotta cheese, spinach, and fresh tomatoes that come on it. Be sure you save enough room to try their cannoli dish for desert.
4. Natili North
Family owned and operated since 1973, Natili North will serve you a slice that you’ll taste the years of family tradition in with every bite. Start out with an order of their famous French-fried mushrooms for a real treat to get your tastebuds going. When it comes time for your pie, we like their Buffalo Chicken the best. Provolone cheese combines with perfectly seasoned buffalo chicken with just the right amount of spicy kick.
5. Anna Maria’s
The team at Anna Maria’s takes pride in making their pies the old-fashioned way: hand-tossed and home-made. The result is some seriously impressive flavors. You’ll love the sweet and savory combination of their Hawaiian pie, with pineapple and ham working together beautifully to make a one-of-a-kind taste. For a decadent treat afterwards, order a fresh-baked peanut butter filled brownie.
We really appreciated the friendly service these pizzerias gave to us on our visit and that they give every day to members of our community. We keep that same sort of community spirit alive at our dealership, striving to treat every customer like the neighbors you are. Come on in to Mike Kelly Hyundai to experience the local difference!