Blog / Best Pizza in Butler

Top 5 Pizza Joints in Butler, PA

Pizza in Butler, PA
    It's a source of constant debate here in our town: where can you get the very best pizza in the area? We've got plenty of great pizzerias to choose from here in Butler, PA, so the question can be a controversial one. To add our voice to this ongoing argument, we decided to put together a list of our five favorite spots to grab a slice here in town. Check them out for a pie that is sure to please.

1. Mac's Brick Oven Pizzeria

If you've never experienced the difference a brick oven makes in the taste of your pie's crust, you've got to get down to Mac's to give their authentic brick-oven style pies. Their White Traditional pie shows you that you don't need tomato sauce to make a decent slice, topped with fresh garlic, oregano, basil, a blend of mozzarella and parmesan cheese with a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil for a refreshing flavor.

2. Villa Grande Ristorante and Pizzeria

While any of the Italian classics served up at Villa Grande are worth checking out, it's hard to beat the pies they bake up here. Our favorite is their Ricotta and Meatballs pie, with homemade meatballs complimented perfectly by dollops of ricotta cheese and fresh mozzarella, all served on a base of San Marzano tomato sauce. Get yours with a side of their tasty tomato bruschetta.

3. Tani's

Conveniently located just off of Butler Street, Tani's is the go-to spot for many locals when they're craving a slice. After trying it out for ourselves, we can certainly see why. We tried the Florence pie, and were treated to some zesty flavors from the ricotta cheese, spinach, and fresh tomatoes that come on it. Be sure you save enough room to try their cannoli dish for desert.

4. Natili North

Family owned and operated since 1973, Natili North will serve you a slice that you'll taste the years of family tradition in with every bite. Start out with an order of their famous French-fried mushrooms for a real treat to get your tastebuds going. When it comes time for your pie, we like their Buffalo Chicken the best. Provolone cheese combines with perfectly seasoned buffalo chicken with just the right amount of spicy kick.

5. Anna Maria's

The team at Anna Maria's takes pride in making their pies the old-fashioned way: hand-tossed and home-made. The result is some seriously impressive flavors. You'll love the sweet and savory combination of their Hawaiian pie, with pineapple and ham working together beautifully to make a one-of-a-kind taste. For a decadent treat afterwards, order a fresh-baked peanut butter filled brownie. We really appreciated the friendly service these pizzerias gave to us on our visit and that they give every day to members of our community. We keep that same sort of community spirit alive at our dealership, striving to treat every customer like the neighbors you are. Come on in to Mike Kelly Hyundai to experience the local difference!
Posted in:

Related Posts

Pizza in Butler, PA

3 Pizza Places You Should Know About in Butler, PA

A cheesy slice of heaven can turn around any bad day. The next time you are looking for a great pizza place, check out these three Butler gems. Italian Village Pizza Italian Village Pizza has served delicious Italian lunches and dinner since 1980. The menu includes a wide variety of starters, such as breadsticks, meatballs, and wings. You can create a pizza from a wide array of toppings and sauces. Specialty pizzas include a Supreme White Pizza, Carnivore's Special, and the new Burrata Margherita that features fresh basil and buttery Burrata cheese. All pizzas are available with either a Napolitana (extra thin) or thick Sicilian crust. Gluten-free and cauliflower crusts are available for those with special dietary needs. Other menu options include calzone, stromboli, and the local-favorite Village Rolls. These scrumptious rolls are made from pizza dough stuffed with mozzarella, Parmesan, and your choice of pepperoni, sausage, steak, or spinach. Homemade soups, salads, baked hoagies, burgers, cheesesteaks, and pasta dishes round out the menu. For dessert, Italian Village Pizza offers hand-filled cannoli and zeppole. You can find Italian Village Pizza at 101 Clearview Circle. The restaurant opens at 11 a.m. every day. Online ordering and delivery are available. Pizza Pie Pizza Pie is a great place to enjoy a cheesy slice with friends and family. Appetizers include stuffed hot sausage rolls, stuffed peppers, fried zucchini, and wings. The pizza menu has something for everyone. You can create a pie with your choice of traditional thin or thick Sicilian crust, made fresh daily. Gourmet pizzas include a Hawaiian, chicken bacon ranch, and a Pittsburgh-area special: the Pierogi Pizza. Other menu items include calzones, hoagies, salads, and pasta dinners such as chicken Romano and stuffed shells. Be sure to check out the daily specials Pizza Pie is at 1734 North Main Street Extension. Restaurant hours are Monday through Thursday from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m, Friday and Saturday from 11 a.m. to 11 p.m., and Sunday noon to 9 p.m. Mac's Brick Oven Pizza Mac's Brick Oven Pizza is the newest pizza place in Butler, but it is already gathering a following. Owned by a local family, Mac's is dedicated to using the highest quality, locally-sourced ingredients. It's the only pizza place in town that uses a dual-fired brick oven to bake pizzas. The menu at Mac's includes starters such as Burrata Caprese, a twist on the traditional Caprese salad featuring buttery burrata cheese, and served with toasted crostini. Mac's artisan pizza is always hand-tossed. The menu includes lots of vegetarian pies as well as meat-heavy pizzas. The Wild Mushroom pie is a favorite among vegetarians, made from a traditional white pizza topped with wild mushrooms, fresh thyme, creme fraiche, and mozzarella. Dessert items include tiramisu, homemade cannoli, and cinnamon sugar bites. You can visit Mac's Brick Oven Pizza at 120 E. Jefferson St. It's open Tuesday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Whether you love a simple cheese pie or one with the works, the pizza restaurants in Butler have something for everyone. Check out any of these three pizza places the next time you crave a slice.   Image via Pixabay.com by Riedelmeier

Hyundai Santa Fe SUV parked in desert landscape with mountains background

2026 Hyundai Santa Fe Hybrid vs. Gas: Which Is the Better Fit for Butler, PA Drivers?

Shopping for a 2026 Hyundai Santa Fe at Mike Kelly Hyundai in Butler, PA, presents two excellent powertrain options. The Hyundai Santa Fe hybrid vs gas choice remains a common question for SUV buyers. Both configurations provide three rows of seating, a bold exterior, and abundant standard features, yet their distinct performance profiles cater to different driving needs. Our team is ready to provide more information to help you select the perfect fit. Understanding the Two Powertrain Options A 2.5L turbocharged four-cylinder engine powers the gas 2026 Santa Fe, generating 277 horsepower and 311 pound-feet of torque. This robust setup supports a 3,500-pound towing capacity on most trims, while the XRT trim can tow up to 4,500 pounds with trailer brakes. Alternatively, the Santa Fe Hybrid combines a 1.6L turbocharged four-cylinder engine with an electric motor for a 231-horsepower combined output. The hybrid supplies reliable, smooth performance suitable for daily commutes and extended road trips. Fuel Efficiency: Where the Hybrid Shines The hybrid trim clearly leads in fuel economy comparisons. In front-wheel drive configuration, the hybrid achieves an EPA-estimated 36 city and 35 highway miles per gallon, greatly improving upon the gas model's ratings. These figures accumulate into notable savings for drivers frequently navigating local roads or taking long highway trips. The gas Santa Fe operates efficiently for its class, but the hybrid yields a distinct advantage for families focused on lowering fuel costs. Trim Options and Key Features Hyundai offers both powertrains across multiple trim levels packed with advanced features. Every Santa Fe includes a 12.3" touchscreen, wireless Apple CarPlay©, wireless Android Auto©, Bluelink +© connectivity, and a hands-free smart liftgate. Standard Hyundai SmartSense safety technology provides Forward Collision-Avoidance Assist, Lane Following Assist, Driver Attention Warning, and Safe Exit Assist. Higher-tier gas and hybrid models feature Remote Smart Parking Assist, a Bose© premium 12-speaker audio system, Blind-Spot View Monitor, and optional Nappa leather seating. The hybrid lineup ranges from SE through Calligraphy, while the gas lineup exclusively features the off-road XRT trim with all-terrain tires and increased ground clearance. Which One Is Right for You? Selecting a powertrain depends on your driving priorities. The hybrid appeals to buyers looking to maximize fuel efficiency and secure the 10-year/100,000-mile hybrid battery warranty. The gas model suits those needing higher horsepower, elevated towing capacity, or the rugged capability of the XRT trim. Both setups include Hyundai's exceptional 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain limited warranty and 5-year/60,000-mile new vehicle limited warranty. Visit Mike Kelly Hyundai to Explore Both Options Contact the Mike Kelly Hyundai team in Butler, PA, to experience the 2026 Santa Fe firsthand. Our staff can help you find the right trim, compare real inventory, and explore available offers. The 2026 Santa Fe proves itself as a well-rounded SUV in either configuration. Discover which powertrain aligns with your family needs by visiting us online at https://www.mikekellyhyundai.com today.

Hyundai Tucson SUV parked on forest trail near trees

How the 2026 Hyundai Tucson's AWD Handles Western PA Winters

Winter driving in western Pennsylvania is no joke. Between snow, icy back roads, and unpredictable temperature swings, you need a vehicle that can handle whatever the season throws at you. The 2026 Hyundai Tucson AWD is built with that kind of confidence in mind - and drivers in Butler, PA, have good reason to check it out. What Makes HTRAC AWD Worth Your Attention H yundai's HTRAC All Wheel Drive system, is available across all gas-powered trims of the 2026 Hyundai Tucson. HTRAC continuously monitors road conditions and distributes power between the front and rear axels as needed, giving you better grip when roads get slippery. It's not just a feature you'll pull out in emergencies - it works every time conditions change. For anyone driving on Butler County roads or snowy highways during a western PA winter, that kind of responsive traction management makes a difference when conditions get tough. A Capable Lineup of Tucson Trims One of the advantages of the 2026 Tucson is how much flexibility you have when configuring your build. The lineup includes the SE, SEL, SEL Plus, XRT, SEL Premium, and Limited trims, giving you plenty of options depending on your budget and feature preferences. HTRAC AWD is available on all trims, so you're not forced into a top-level package just to get the all-weather capability you need. The Hyundai Tucson AWD winter performance story doesn't end at the drivetrain, either. The Tucson also earned a 2026 NHTSA 5-Star Overall Safety Rating, which speaks to how seriously Hyundai takes protecting the people inside the vehicle - a factor that is even more important when roads are unpredictable. Technology and Safety Features for Cold-Weather Driving Modern winters call for more than just good tires and AWD. The 2026 Tucson comes loaded with safety and technology features designed to keep you informed and protected. Hyundai's Bluelink + connected car service lets you remotely start the vehicle and turn on the climate control before you even step outside, so you can warm up the cabin and defrost the windshield without going out in the cold. The 2026 Hyundai Tucson's cabin is anchored by a 12.3-in touchscreen, a panoramic curved display combining dual 12.3-in screens, wireless Apple CarPlay® and Android Auto™, a 12-in head-up display, Hyundai Digital Key 2 smartphone access, and over-the-air update capabilities. A Hard-To-Beat Warranty Winters can be tough on vehicles, which makes Hyundai's coverage package especially reassuring. Every new Hyundai comes backed by America's Best Warranty, offering coverage for up to 10 years or 100,000 miles. You also get five years of 24/7 roadside assistance with no mileage cap - a feature that can be a lifesaver when you're stuck in a snowstorm miles from home. The Hyundai Tucson AWD winter package essentially comes with a built-in safety net, and that's hard to put a price on. Come See the 2026 Tucson at Mike Kelly Hyundai If you're shopping for an SUV that can handle western Pennsylvania winters, the 2026 Hyundai Tucson AWD deserves a spot at the top of your list. Between its capable HTRAC system, impressive safety rating, and thoughtful technology, it's a well-rounded choice for year-round driving. Stop by Mike Kelly Hyundai or visit us online at mikekellyhyundai.com to explore current inventory and find the Tucson trim that fits your needs. If you're preparing for the first snowfall or just looking for more confidence on every drive, the team at Mike Kelly Hyundai is ready to help.